Review: Griffin TuneFlex AUX HandsFree

I’ve been a longtime user and fan of Griffin Technology’s products. One area Griffin has always excelled in was integrating my iPod, well, now iPhone, into my car. Shortly after I bought my iPhone 3G a couple years ago, Griffin released the TuneFlex AUX SmartClick. The SmartClick had this super handy remote you could attach to your steering wheel to control playback. This was one of the most useful accessories I ever owned. You can read my glowing review from back in January 2009.

Sadly, when the iPhone 4 came out, the SmartClick’s model-specific adapters didn’t accommodate the new shape of the iPhone 4. So I’ve been patiently waiting for a revised TuneFlex.

A couple weeks ago, Griffin released the TuneFlex AUX HandsFree. The main features are an adjustable cradle that can accommodate the various shapes of iPod and iPhone models, even while the device is in a case, and a microphone that will allow you to talk on the phone handsfree. Hence the name.

I saw this pop up on Amazon for $32, which is quite the discount from the $49.99 MSRP, so I ordered it.

In seven years, this is the first time I am disappointed with a Griffin product. Sadly, the HandsFree is four steps backwards in design from the SmartClick. Sadly, I’ll be returning it for the reasons listed below.

  1. The new, adjustable cradle doesn’t apply enough tension to keep the iPhone 4 seated well on the Dock connector. The iPhone wobbles around a lot. With the Dock connector providing the only apparent point of stability, I’m afraid either the connector on the TuneFlex will snap, or worse, the port on the iPhone will be damaged.
  2. On both the SmarClick and Handsfree editions of the TuneFlex, the point at which the gooseneck meets the cradle swivels to the left and right. On the SmartClick, it had ratchet points to provide resistance in swiveling. The HandsFree has a completely smooth action. Too smooth. A modestly hard turn will definitely cause the swivel point to swing and, combined with the loose tension in the cradle, will likely send your iPhone or iPod flying across the cabin.
  3. There is no way to control playback anymore. I do much more listening with my iPhone than talking in the car. Having to fiddle with onscreen controls to skip forward a track or pause is more dangerous. The SmartClick had such an excellent solution to this. The HandsFree offers no solution.
  4. Audio on the SmartClick was line-out via the Dock connector. The HandsFree offers only audio out via the headphone jack, so you first have to adjust the device’s volume, then your stereo’s. What a distraction and a mess. Never mind the fact that if you forget to turn down the device’s volume before you plug in headphones you’ll have hurting ears.

I really wish I had better things to say about this product. It actually kind of hurts to lampoon a Griffin product since I have never had a bad experience from them.

It’s a shame they didn’t just release a $10 adapter for the iPhone 4 for SmartClick owners.

Rethinking iChat

Bjango makes fantastic apps for iOS and Mac OS X. I use their hugely popular iStat utility every day. They pose the question on their blog of “What if iChat was one window?”

Their mockup and explanation is top notch and a great read. My favorite line from the whole thing is:

I’m finding more and more that the best way to design desktop apps is to imagine you’re building them for iOS.

I couldn’t agree more. I hope someone at Apple is listening.

Blu-ray is a Bag of Hurt

As Steve Jobs famously said back in October 2008, during the unveiling of the unibody MacBook and MacBook Pro, blu-ray is a bag of hurt. I have found this out first hand in the past 24 hours. Yesterday, I bought Iron Man 2 in a Blu-ray, DVD, and Digital Copy set. I saw the movie in theaters and loved it, so adding it to my collection was a no-brainer. But once I got it home, the pain began.

First off, I love the picture quality of Blu-ray (or rather, HD, whether or not it’s on a disc). What I hate, however, is Digital Rights Management, or DRM. In layman’s terms – copy protection. The reason I hate it so much is the undue burden it puts on the average consumer. I experienced such a burden last night.

The movie industry is constantly changing the DRM scheme on new movies, requiring your Blu-ray player to be updated constantly with new firmware to decode the new schemes. What I have fallen into is something I figured would be unlikely. The manufacturer of my player has stopped providing updates.

I hadn’t noticed as I hadn’t bought a new release in quite some time, but LG last updated my BD-390 in April. Iron Man 2 freezes in playback every 20 minutes, and when you press rewind or fast-forward to get over the freeze, it forgets where it was at and drops you ten minutes back in the movie.

At first, I figured it was a defective disc, so I exchanged it. The new disc exhibited the same problem. I decided to experiment a little. I picked a different part of the movie to start from, watched about 20 minutes, and freeze. Same behavior. I nudged past the freeze, watched about 20 minutes, freeze. Rinse, repeat. So it isn’t a physical anomaly in the disc.

I checked for updates via the WiFi connection of my player. Nothing. So I went to Google. It appears that many owners of the LG BD-390 are experiencing the same exact issue. Even worse, folks who have purchased movies made by Lionsgate films that were released since May have had their LG BD-390 spit the disc right back out.

LG lists the BD-390 as discontinued. We’re talking about a 10-month old player that was the top of the game last November. It sure seems like LG has given up on supporting new firmware for a discontinued device.

I talked with LG’s support, and the representative told me my report would be filed with the firmware team. I’m not very confident.

This whole mess is because of constantly changing DRM schemes, and companies discontinuing support for those schemes. I do love the Blu-ray experience when it works. This is the first bump I’ve hit with it, but it doesn’t bode well for the format.

Quite simply, DRM needs to go away, just like it did with music downloads. It’s time to trust the majority of consumers, because DRM sure as heck doesn’t stop the pirates. It just slows them down.

Apple's Remote App for iOS Gets Updated

New icon, support for the iPad (finally), and also scaled up for the Retina Display. The iPad interface is very enjoyable. You can see your entire library, including videos and podcasts. Looks a lot like iTunes 10.

Another nice feature is support for Home Sharing. Log in with your Home Sharing credentials and you instantly see all the libraries on your Home Share. Much nicer than walking to every computer or Apple TV and dealing with PIN codes.

I can’t wait for AirPlay compatible speakers from third parties to arrive.

HDR Photos on the iPhone 4

One of my favorite features of the recently released iOS 4.1 update is HDR photos on the iPhone 4. HDR stands for High Dynamic Range, and Wikipedia explains it as such:

[...]high dynamic range imaging (HDRI or just HDR) is a set of techniques that allow a greater dynamic range of luminance between the lightest and darkest areas of an image than standard digital imaging techniques or photographic methods. This wider dynamic range allows HDR images to more accurately represent the wide range of intensity levels found in real scenes, ranging from direct sunlight to faint starlight.

Basically, if a beautiful blue sky is blown out to white in a normally exposed photograph, an HDR of the same scene, composed of three shots at different exposures, will more than likely show the sky along with the rest of the scene.

As an example, examine the differences in this photo I took between the normal, single shot exposure on top and the three-exposure HDR of the same scene below.

Normally, it is a time-consuming process to create HDR photos, at least for beginners. I would throw myself in this category. But the iPhone 4 is automatically taking care of all the messy stuff. Just click the HDR On toggle in the Camera app, tap to focus, then take the shot. The iPhone 4 will automatically take three exposures, and then mesh them together into an HDR. The is a preference in the Camera section of Settings.app on your iPhone to save the original exposure. It is on by default.

The camera on the iPhone 4 was already one of my favorite features, but built-in, easy as pie HDR has added just that much more value. If you have an iPhone 4 and haven’t played with HDR yet, shame on you.

So Long, Genius Sidebar

In a rather odd move, Apple released a software update for iTunes 10 this morning. Why is that odd? It’s Saturday. The release of iTunes 10.0.1 brought several needed bug fixes and replaced the Genius sidebar with the Ping sidebar.

Now, I expect bug fixes in a maintenance level update, but I have to say removing the Genius sidebar was a mistake. Apple’s Genius algorithm is darn near magic at how well it matches songs up for playlists and how well it was at suggesting similar music to what I like. Now, Genius playlists are still around (thankfully), but the sidebar, the part that recommended new music to me, is history.

Since I don’t listen to the radio often, Genius was pretty much the only way I discovered new music. Apple’s hope is that Ping will drive more music discovery (and sales). The catch is, I really don’t share a lot of musical taste as most of my friends. Heck, hardly anyone I am connected with on Ping is using it. All in all, Ping, as a social network, kind of sucks.

For years, I have wishing each September for a better iTunes – a rewritten, rethought iTunes. Sadly, each year it just piles on more cruft on legacy design. iTunes 10, as a whole, seems a bit more optimized than iTunes 9 was. And in all my years of using iTunes, never has a maintenance update actually made the overall value of the app worse.

As much as I still hope for a complete overhaul of iTunes, in the short term I will hope for iTunes 10.0.2 to give users a preference to toggle whether they want Genius or Ping to reside in the sidebar. If you agree, let Apple know.

Mark It Down

For the past five years since I started blogging, I’ve relied mainly on using WYSIWYG editors (first Blogger, then Wordpress, and now Squarespace) and occasionally switching into raw HTML when needed to finesse a few things. I recently noticed that my current host, Squarespace, offers several different markup styles including one I’ve been wanting to try out called Markdown, which is coincidentally developed by one of my favorite writers, John Gruber.

Why Am I Subjecting My Readers to a Mundane Post?

  • Because I can.
  • I figure the best way to experiment with Markdown is simply to write using the syntax.
  • I paid for this site.
  • Hopefully this formats as an unordered list.

or

  1. Because I can.
  2. I figure the best way to experiment with Markdown is simply to write using the syntax.
  3. I paid for this site.
  4. Hopefully this formats as an ordered list.

What is the point of Markdown over Vanilla HTML?

Good question. The Markdown documentation states:

Markdown is a text-to-HTML conversion tool for web writers. Markdown allows you to write using an easy-to-read, easy-to-write plain text format, then convert it to structurally valid XHTML (or HTML).

Thus, “Markdown” is two things: (1) a plain text formatting syntax; and (2) a software tool, written in Perl, that converts the plain text formatting to HTML.

And here is why I’m attracted to using it:

The overriding design goal for Markdown’s formatting syntax is to make it as readable as possible. The idea is that a Markdown-formatted document should be publishable as-is, as plain text, without looking like it’s been marked up with tags or formatting instructions. While Markdown’s syntax has been influenced by several existing text-to-HTML filters, the single biggest source of inspiration for Markdown’s syntax is the format of plain text email.

How Am I Liking Markdown So Far?

Well, just a few paragraphs in, I already like it. I previewed the post a moment ago to see how things are going, and found that the equivalent of <H2> tags looked too big so I easily bumped it down to <H3> by just adding an extra # symbol. Nice.

It’s definitely much faster to encode something like a link to my wife’s blog than to do it via WYSIWYG.

I am a little unsure how to get a link to target offsite and show the offsite indicator in Markdown syntax. I don’t see an example in the syntax documentation.

Thanks for making it through my little test. Not sure if I will stick with Markdown or not, but I could see it happening with a bit more practice. (Don’t worry, I won’t let you know next time, I just wanted to write about my experience in real time).

New iPods and Apple TV Might As Well Be Hotcakes

Because that is what they are going to sell like. A few hours ago, Apple held its usual fall iPod refresh event to set things up for the holiday season. And as an added bonus, Apple live streamed the event on their site, a first since 2002.

Steve Jobs handled the keynote solo style today, save for one developer demo. As many of you know, Jobs has had some major medical issues over the past couple years, culminating in a leave of absence and a life-saving liver transplant. When he returned to Apple, the fall iPod event was his first round of stage time. That was one year ago, and he appeared exhausted and frail. Today was completely different. He looked healthy, was energetic, and even cracked a number of jokes. Glad to see you’re well, Mr. Jobs.

Steve kicked off the event by recognizing Steve Wozniak, co-founder of Apple, who was in the audience. Then he talked about the success of Apple’s retail operations. Next, the overall health of the App Store. And then, with all the numbers out of the way, the really good stuff.

iOS 4.1

Steve introduced iOS 4.1, available for download next week, and ran through some of the updates. He explained there are a lot of bug fixes, primarily with the proximity sensor of iPhone 4, issues with Bluetooth, and performance with iPhone 3G (and presumably second-generation iPod touch, as the hardware is similar). 

There are several new features landing as well. The camera is getting an HDR (High Dynamic Range) photo setting. Basically, turn it on, and the iPhone will take three photos in rapid succession at different exposures, then meld them all together to present a perfectly exposed photo, in theory. As I am a bit of a camera nerd, I have a feeling I will love this simple implementation. Honestly, these days I take more pictures with my iPhone 4 than my Canon 40D.

iOS 4.1 will also allow HD Video uploading to YouTube and MobileMe when connected to WiFi, TV show rentals, and the introduction of Game Center.

Game Center is all about multiplayer games. You can challenge friends or be auto matched with a stranger. You can also compare scores on a leader board and discover new games. Game Center will be an app on your device, but also an API for developers to integrate Game Center into their games.

iOS 4.2

Yes, you read that right, Steve also talked about iOS 4.2. The primary mission of iOS 4.2 is to bring everything in iOS 4.1 to the iPad (finally). A couple other features will be wireless printing and AirPlay. I’ll talk about AirPlay in a bit. iOS 4.2 will be a free update to iPhones, iPod touches, and iPads in November.

iPod

Steve said the secret to the success of the iPod is that Apple has never rested on its laurels. Seems true enough to me. And these new models are very impressive.

iPod shuffle

Starting with the iPod shuffle, Steve took a walk down memory lane and discussed the first, second, and third generation of the shuffle. People loved the first one, went nuts for the second (which I have long said was the perfection of the shuffle design), and that the third wasn’t much of a hit. See, Apple had removed all of the controls from the third generation, moving them all to the headphones. What a disaster. Well, the fourth generation brings back the controls, and looks like a slightly smaller version of the second generation. The shuffle comes in silver, blue, green, orange, or pink. It has a 15 hour battery and will be available next week at $49 for 2GB.

iPod nano

Apple has heralded the death of the click wheel, the iconic input method of mobile music player history. The new iPod nano has a 1.5” touch screen, a clip on the back like the shuffle (runners won’t need a silly armband for it), dedicated volume buttons, and does still have enough room for the 30-pin Dock connector.

The new nano is, however, missing a few features that the last generation had. Those would be the video camera, the ability to play video, and games. In fact, the interface looks a lot like iOS, even down to putting icons in jiggly mode and rearranging them. But, I’m not sure if it is iOS or just looks like iOS. (My wager is that it is iOS, but locked down). 

The new nano is quite the compelling redesign. It will also be available next week in silver, black, blue, green, orange, pink, and red. It has a 24-hour battery and comes in 8GB and 16GB, selling for $149 and $179, respectively.

iPod touch

Apple added a lot to the iPod touch and somehow made it even thinner. The new iPod touch gains the A4 processor found in the iPad and iPhone 4, the amazing Retina Display (by far my favorite feature of the iPhone 4), a 3-axis gyroscope, and not one, but two cameras! The is a camera on the back that can record HD video, but sadly takes fairly low resolution photos, and then a camera on the front for — wait for it — FaceTime video conferencing! I have a feeling this may be popular with some of my relatives. I know FaceTime was indispensable for my son and I when my wife went out of town for a week last month.

The new iPod touch will be available next week, running iOS 4.1 with Game Center. It will be available in capacities of 8GB, 32GB, and 64GB at $229, $299, and $399, respectively.

Sidenote: Unlike previous years, all three capacities are the new generation of iPod touch. Traditionally, Apple has relegated the previous generation to the 8GB slot. This time, all three carry cameras, Retina displays, and A4 chips. Color me impressed.

iPod classic

Not even a mention in the keynote. Not pictured in the iPod family lineup. I thought it may finally be dead. But no, there it sits, unchanged from last year, on Apple’s site. A relic now in more way than one, what with the spinning hard drive and the click wheel. I will be truly surprised if the classic still exists as a product after next year’s fall event.

iTunes

Apple unleashed the tenth major iteration of iTunes, iTunes 10. Steve explained that since the iTunes Store is about to surpass CD sales, they decided to ditch the CD out of the icon. I very much like the look of the new icon. I’ve thought for a while that the CD sure seemed dated this day and age.

Other enhancements, according to Apple, are a new hybrid view, where you’ll get album artwork for 5 or more songs that are from the same album in list view. 

Apple also set out to strengthen music discovery by creating a new social network inside iTunes called Ping. Follow artists and friends and be followed, create a circle of friends, post your thoughts and opinions, see customized song & album charts, and see concert listings. 

I’m not too sure about Ping, but I have yet to try it out, as iTunes 10 went from “Available Today” to “Coming Soon.”

One last note that I noticed from the screen shots is that the close, minimize, and zoom buttons (at least on the Mac) have gone from being horizontal to vertical and in line next to the player controls, saving ¼” of space of vertical window real estate. It’s a small thing, and seems odd compared to the rest of Mac OS X, but let’s face it, screens are getting wider, not taller. I like it, and I hope the rest of Mac OS X goes this way in the next major update.

One More Thing Hobby

Since the introduction of the Apple TV in 2007, Apple has referred to it as a hobby. The hardware had remained unchanged except for a hard drive bump from 40GB to 160GB. But it’s the one Apple product I can think of that hasn’t had much success. Why? Well, according to Apple, customers want Hollywood movies & TV shows, everything in HD, lower prices for content, no reliance upon a computer, no worrying about managing storage, no syncing, and they want it to be silent, cool, and small.

The new Apple TV is ¼ the size of the old, fits in your hand, the content is in HD, and is on a rental model. HD movie rentals are available day and date with DVD releases for $4.99, and TV shows are available to rent for 99¢. The content is streamed straight to the device, and there is even support for Netflix Instant.

AirPlay

Now let’s talk about AirPlay. There’s been a technology in the AirPort Express called AirTunes for a while now, which let you stream music from iTunes to speakers connected to an Airport Express. AirPlay replaces that, and expands upon it. One feature of AirPlay is the ability for any iOS device to stream content to an Apple TV. And not just music, but videos and photos too. Let’s say you’re watching a movie on your iPad, but you decide to move to the living room. A couple taps, and the iPad pushes the movie onto your TV via the Apple TV. Same goes for an iPhone or iPod touch. This feature will come with iOS 4.2.

Another expansion of AirPlay is it won’t be limited to AirPort Express and Apple TV. Third parties will be able to embed AirPlay compatibility into their devices. According to Engadget:

That means you’ll be able to stream music from iTunes, your iPhone, iPod touch or iPad to speaker docks, receivers and stereos from companies like Denon, Marantz, Bowers & Wilkins, JBL and iHome, complete with song, album, and artist info and album art.

Sounds like a winner to me.

Wrap Up

Overall, I think it was a great event. I hope the trend will be to live stream keynotes in the future. I know my mother is already green with envy for the new green iPod nano, though I’d rather her have an iPod touch for FaceTime (are you reading this, Mom?) I’d be surprised if these new iPods aren’t on a few of my relatives’ Christmas lists. 

Apple to Live Stream Fall Event

From Apple’s press release:

Apple® will broadcast its September 1 event online using Apple’s industry-leading HTTP Live Streaming, which is based on open standards. Viewing requires either a Mac® running Safari® on Mac OS® X version 10.6 Snow Leopard®, an iPhone® or iPod touch® running iOS 3.0 or higher, or an iPad™. The live broadcast will begin at 10:00 a.m. PDT on September 1, 2010 at www.apple.com.

The last time Apple did this was in the late 90’s 2002, I think — you know, back in the day when most folks didn’t have enough bandwidth to even stream video.

Needless to say, I’ll have a live blog or two open in tabs in case the stream goes down, but I am very excited to see it in action.

Also, if you’ve followed any of the rumors swirling about the Apple TV possibly getting live streaming support, then the text of Apple’s press release is interesting, as Andy Ihnatko pointed out earlier.

Pages Gets Friendly with iBooks

Apple’s iWork ‘09 suite received a software update today addressing some bugs in all three apps. Pages, however, has a new feature hidden amongst those bug fixes — Export to ePub. 

ePub is the eBook format that Apple is using for its iBooks app on iOS. Now, anyone with iWork ‘09 can turn a document into an ePub file for use as a DRM-free book that they can distribute themselves, or presumably upload to iTunes for inclusion in the iBookstore. 

Pages certainly isn’t the only tool out there capable of doing this, but it’s a nice feature for iWork users. 

Apple has also provided a support document for advising when an ePub or PDF is better suited for your document, and how to go about creating that ePub.